What they're saying in Ann Arbor, elsewhere about AnnArbor.com

There's talking going on in Ann Arbor, Michigan, where the Ann Arbor News and the Ann Arbor Chronicle covered the first community meetings being held to seek feedback on the new products under the AnnArbor.com umbrella:

• Content director Tony Dearing: AnnArbor.com focus will be "local"
• AnnArbor.com leaders address comunity concerns about local coverage
  
• Social networking to be implemented
• AnnArbor.com Execs Answer Questions
• Local flavor to new site

Some Michigan journalists may remember David Sullivan, who worked for The Flint Journal and in the Ann Arbor market before moving east. He was on vacation when the news about the Michigan newspapers broke. He comes back with his take on it in The Mysterious Ann Arbor.

Follow some of the AnnArbor.com conversation here:

• The Twitter Buzz on AnnArbor.com
• The FriendFeed AnnArbor.com feed

That's how I found a blog post with a suggestion for Michigan reporters losing their jobs in the Ann Arbor region. LivingBlue asks Is Web an Opportunity for Laid-Off Newspaper Reporters?

Or those reporters could go into the medical field - those jobs are hard to ship overseas.

Blogger: Print's death to dam river of news

Peel away the specifics of sports in this writing to discover a fear articulated for many as formal media organizations give way to blogging.

There's also a challenge here for sports teams, governments, organizations, businesses - what mechanism will each set up to determine how information will be available.

Do all audience members now get a copy of the meeting packets distributed to reporters and board members? Should an organization's president talk to me because I share news and opinions via a blog or distribute a newsletter? Does the lack of a printed newspaper obligate governement bodies to publish their minutes faster?


The process of news

Maize n Brew Dave writes on college football, specifically University of Michigan football. But today, he focuses on the process of news.

"As much as we loathe the columnists that have colored our opinion of their employers, newspapers served a critical purpose. They facilitated the flow of information from people who had it to people who didn't."

Yes, it is possible for a sports blogger to get access to information because universities are increasing what they put online and through the blossoming of sports sites where coaches, players and fans input detailed statistics.


Three tiers of news

Maize n Brew Dave suggests that the current system is set up for three tiers (at least for college fooball):

1) The University (school, coaches and players) possess the information;

2) the credentialed press gets the first crack at it;

3) and the rest of us are left to sort through what reaches us.

The differences

The differences boil down to credentialed press not using cleaned up, message-on-target quotes from the official sources. Instead, tha press can give, as Maize n Brew Dave says:

"Perspective on what was said and how questions were answered. They asked tough questions on decisions and results. They could observe the reactions from coaches, gage responses first hand, and had the ability to ask the questions where we do not."

Some of the perspective that comes from access to the paper and electronic versions of stories published before. Some of the perspective that comes from ongoing observations of coaches and players, perspective grown from the luxury of paid-for time spent on the specific subject.

A blogger's role

Maize n Brew Dave reminds us to remember the source of content and the intent of the message. But much of his writing explores the notion of once counterculture bloggers now becoming the main source of news in many communities. He looks at the obligation and responsibility of bloggers to provide insights based on raw reporting rather then reactions to what others have gathered.

And then there's this:

"When people begin turning to your blog for new information, you can't let them down. If you do, you lose their trust and their readership. "

A blogger's burden

Wow. That alone is a huge burden as I learned when people began turning here for information about Advance Publications, or my take on AnnArbor.com and Advance Internet because of my interest in the corporation that is funding my pension (we hope).

It was almost too easy to slip back into workaholic hours, seeking pieces of information scattered in announcements and blogs, while knowing family beating cancer is my first priority. It is tempting to want to email or call people I've known to get the "real story" or at least more details to help my friends in the industry, while knowing how uncomfortable it can be learning that you confided in a media person, not a friend.

Just a kick

Jim Carty of Paper Tiger No More said in State of the Blog, after his coverage of the Ann Arbor Press shutting down and AnnArbor.com helped draw 12,000 unique visitors to his site over four days:

"But that's just sort of a kick. There's no point to it, no goal. Paper Tiger isn't ever going to be a commercial venture, it's not supposed to be, it's just me being me, for better or for worse."

Jim, who left sports reporting at the Ann Arbor News to go to law school, wrote:

"The constant updates were the product of an extraordinary situation that affected me, and many of my friends, very personally. It will be viewed as an aberration in the long run. For the most part, the day-to-day shtick around here much more resembles random snark on newspapers, politics and sports, some law school musings, and me promoting stuff written by my journalism cronies."

My fingers unveil thinking

Inside Out is a way for me continue thinking by writing, looking at change and changes and figuring out what I'm going to do today and tomorrow. How can journalism and community not be a part of it when I've been immersed in some form of it since at least 1966.

Inside Out is the place where I can write about posts like The Death of the Print Newspaper and the Birth of the New Blogsphere. as I decide which project gets my eyes next.

Thanks for visiting.

Can pay model work for 50k newspaper? Cable TV model?

The idea of paying for content online gets tossed around frequently online and at gatherings of newspaper people. But not many people take the time to put numbers in a spreadsheet. Media Cafe, with help from NAA (Newspaper Association of America), Borrell Associates, AdPerfect and Centro, does.

In this second go-around, Jeff Mignon and Nancy Wang run numbers for a newspaper with 50,000 print subscribers paying $17 a month and a web site getting 250,000 unique visitors eying 2.5 million pages. The nine scenarios include a mix of subscription prices, conversion rates of print subscribers to online and content options. There's an online spreadsheet or a downloadable one but these numbers show only three of the nine options making more revenue, one option that's close and five below current revenue.

The spreadsheet includes the cost of acquiring subscribers, but @jeffjarvis suggested on Twitter the need to calculate impact of lost Googlejuice and brand value in market.

Meanwhile, Martin Langeveld over on Nieman Journalism Lab also puts out some numbers and concludes the math doesn't add up. He suggests that forward-thinking newspapers explore weekly or twice weekly print products, an idea floated in November 2008.

I'm still leaning toward the impossibility of getting people to pay for online news even as I consider how the cable TV model might work:

"Online news services will look something like cable TV. A tiered offering...For $100 bucks a year you get access to 10 national news sites, 10 state, 10 local...for $50 you get ....5 of each...or something along that scale...."

Nothing is impossible if we all keep sharing these ideas.

Multimedia musings: A video on saving newspapers, a Copy Editor's Lament, and some weary journalists to entertain

Life is far too mysterious to be serious all the time, so thanks to Flint Expatriates and the Gannett Blog we can enjoy some outside-the-box revenue generating ideas in the Saving the Newspaper video.

That reminded me I never shared the Copy Editor's Lament (The Layoff Song).

The video is an adaption of song #79 from Jonathan Mann, who set up a goal of a song a day.

"The music is the same, but I enlisted the lip-dub and acting chops of my friends down at the East Bay Express, the local alt-weekly here in the East Bay. Yay!"

Express editor Stephen Buell, who has collected and framed final editions of newspapers since 1982, shares more revenue ideas in New Practices and Revenues for a New Era in Journalism.

"We're not just whining about our finances like the Chronicle. We're doing something about them" says Buell.

The Copy Editor's Lament (The Layoff Song) is from Christopher Ave, political editor at the St. Louis Post-Dispatch. He explained on his blog that copy editors struck him as having the most under-appreciated job in the newsroom.

Here are a few of the words:

'm a human safety net
I double-check the facts and vet
assertions before they are set in type.

I can provide punctuation
appropriate for publication
make the capitalization right.

I was there to fix your grammar
when you thought it wouldn't matter
cut all your extraneous blather down.

Listen to the MP3 for the rest. We'll wait.

Kurt Greenbaum shared a video from some colleagues tagged "Got rest ye weary journalists" back in December. It's seasonal, but I think as long as we're singing I'll share it.

May your day be merry and bright.

The Dearly Departed Daily: Detroit group to hold ‘wake’ for print journalism

Items like this keep my family from getting a meal on time some days.

A search for an update on citizens journalism at the Oakland Press uncovered the wake for "The Dearly Departed Daily" planned by a Detroit group. (The search was related to this post: Michigan media making news again)

Thanks to Elizabeth Voss, who wrote about the event on the Crain-powered Detroit Make It Here site, here's what I know now:

On April 23, one month after the announcement that Michigan would soon lose a major daily newspaper and three Booth Newspapers would trim the printing schedule to three days a week (and combine sections), the Women In Communications of Detroit group will host a wake.

Farewell Newsprint: Hello Digital Media
Women in Communications of Detroit will host Farewell Newsprint: Hello Digital Media at 6 p.m., April 23 at the Doubletree Guest Suites Fort Shelby, 525 W. Lafayette Blvd., Detroit. The cost is $30 for Women in Communications and Society of Professional Journalists members and $35 for nonmembers. Movie fare appetizers are included. A cash bar and specialty coffees are available. Valet parking is $8 or next door surface lot parking is $6. Register by April 20 by online or e-mail at info@womcomdetroit.org or by phone at (248) 652-1460.

Jack Lessenberry, Metro Times columnist, a senior news analyst for Michigan Radio and journalism lecturer at Wayne State University. will lead the wake. He is quoted in the online article, saying he is worried that "people accustomed to getting a print newspaper won’t adjust well to the shift to three-day a week home delivery."

“The real issue is not whether print will survive as a news medium. The real issue is whether journalism keeps going. Thomas Jefferson said how can you possibly have a healthy democracy without journalism?”

After the wake, the event moves into a more positive direction, with Debora Scola, community affairs director for the Detroit Media Partnership, talking to the women’s professional group about changes the Detroit newspapers are making to compete in a digital era. The Detroit Free Press and The News reduced home delivery to three days a week and increased its focusing resources on digital media on Monday.


This first appeared on my Wired Journalists blog.

Michigan media making news again

Just a quick roundup of things I've posted here, there and everywhere or read about Michigan media today.

Livingston County Press cuts staff
My stepmother may have to change her media plans. She was counting on the Livingston County Daily Press and Argus to become her main source for news instead of reading the Detroit newspapers online. The long-time subscriber to the Detroit newspapers had praised the hometown newspaper for its coverage and said it was "good enough" and better than going online to read the news.

But today, an article by Mike Malott probably means the amount and type of news in the Livingston County newspaper will change. At least 10 percent of the staff is being laid off, according to the article. Executive Editor Rich Perlberg declined to specify the total number of layoffs, but said the number was "more than 10" from a total work force of 95.The layoffs included Managing Editor Maria Stuart and Metro Editor-Features Henry "Buddy" Moorehouse.

Perlberg blamed declining advertising.

I found it ironic that Stuart's March 29th column was "What would you do to save a co-worker's job?" She wrote about the efforts of the Howell Education Association. She's followed that up with "The Search for Silver Linings," calling it my chance to say goodbye.

"Lesson learned: In this fast-changing day and age, we should treat every conversation we have as if it is our last. We should leave nothing unspoken."

Moorehouse, who worked for the newspaper for 26 years, also penned a piece: Thank you and goodbye.

Job in Detroit
It's good news that journalism jobs in Michigan are opening. A reTweet of @NancyAndrews: We are posting our job opening for digital host/tv web anchor today. @elishaanderson is in charge of hiring. #dfpchanges

Update: Here's the job posting.

(Did you see that hash tag? #dfpchanges - go to search.twitter.com, type that in, and you can see all the tweets that will tell you about the Detroit Free Press changes; you can even get an #dfpchanges rss feed)

That reminds me that @BillSeitzler said Scripps & Fox create local news sharing deal in Phoenix, Detroit and Tampa; complete story on Broadcasting and Cable.

"Starting this month, the service "will pool content-gathering resources at general market news events, allowing the stations to save on duplicate efforts," the groups said in a statement. "By reducing costs, the stations will be able to increase their focus and resources on specialized franchise reporting." "

In Detroit, the stations are WJBK (Fox) and WXYZ (ABC).

TVNewsDay also reported:

"Content produced by the local news service can be used across multiple platforms, including over-the-air broadcasts, and online and mobile reporting. All employees involved in the shared operation will remain employees of their respective news organizations."

Oakland Press stopping paycheck
The Oakland Press is making news again. Hat tip to Paper Tiger No More, which led me to T.C. Cameron's blog The Write Referee and the post "Sacked by Citizen Journalism." Cameron says that an email informed him the newspaper would no longer pay for the syndicated version of The Write. A followup email invited him to post for free as a citizen journalist - an offer refused.

Cameron is no fan of citizen journalism, a big component of The Oakland Press' strategy.

Cameron says in his blog:

"Citizen journalism is the ingenious creation of editors lacking for legitimate journalistic resources and the financial inducements to compensate said legitimate journalists. As advertising revenue plummets, so does pay for real writers. What newspapers and an endless list of Internet blog sites offer is byline stardom in return for copy. The byline is the payment for the copy. All the newspapers pay for is the editor responsible for making sure it's true -- that's code for a once-over to make sure all the key facts of the story seem to be in place -- and the online platform they publish within."

However, you'll remember that The Oakland Press's executive editor Gil Gilbert said in December 2008 that Citizen Journalism will shape the new face of the Oakland Press.

The paper offered an academy to train citizens interested in contributing to the news organization in mid-Michigan. The first classes had 53 people participating.

Another Gilbert article in January said Citizen Journalism off to a good start, second class scheduled.

Gilbert acknowledged in that article that the idea of citizen journalism attracted some negative attention.

"Where it will lead is anyone’s guess, but it could be interesting. Our goal is to be more of a true voice of the people."

For now, it looks like it will be one less blog on the Oakland Press' web site.

Still waiting to see if other bloggers, like Tim Skubick, will follow. Of course, since Skubick also is now blogging for The Dome, perhaps not him.

Don't send John Hopkins cancer news please 'cause even Johns Hopkins denies it

I understand folks just want to help. That's good because the trend for twentysomethings with cancer is to assume no help is needed. But midway into the fifth month of my daughter's battle I assure you that's not true.

But, before you send me or my daughter the list of things you got via email on the real cancer story look to see what medical center is mentioned. There is no John Hopkins. It is Johns Hopkins. And Johns Hopkins has been saying over and over that the list is not theirs. Here's the December 2008 Johns Hopkins press release.

So if you get a note that starts out something like this:

"AFTER YEARS OF TELLING PEOPLE CHEMOTHERAPY IS THE ONLY WAY TO TRY (TRY BEING THE KEY WORD) AND ELIMINATE CANCER, JOHN HOPKINS IS FINALLY STARTING TO TELL YOU THERE IS AN ALTERNATIVE WAY

Cancer Update from John Hopkins:

1. Every person has cancer cells in the body. These cancer cells do not show up in the standard tests until they have multiplied to a few billion. When doctors tell cancer patients that there are no more cancer cells in their bodies after treatment, it just means the tests are unable to detect the cancer cells because they have not reached the detectable size."

Please know if you get an email that seems unbelievable or you want to check before you send it on, please check it out at Hoax Slayers or Snopes.

As my daughter says over on her Myspace.com page:

"Just wanted to let you know about this email. I have received it several times now and I looked it up on the internet. John Hopkins didn't produce it and doesn't endorse the letter. However they say that some of the life style items could help towards cancer prevention but that the best sites to go for the information regarding food is the www.cancer.gov.

"I found this site that has statements from John Hopkins and information on the plastic container, the freezing and heating them.

She also shares some information about her diet because the "Hopkins" email does have some good diet tips.

"But one has to look them up on the website because some of the items prevent cancer can also cause it. Many vegetarians still get cancer even though they don't consume meat. It's really dependent on if the cancer type was hormone receptive and other genetic types to the cancer cells.

"I thought I would let you know since you stated you weren't sure. The diet I'm doing is mainly organic and hormone growth free meats, eggs, and milk. My reasons for this is my cancer type was homorne receptive to estrogen and proestrogen, and therefore I have to take a med that reduces my hormones in my system, i figure if I cut back the foods that contain hormones then that helps in the long run... I still go out to eat and eat sweets its just more in moderation then before."

So let's end with advice from my daughter:

"I don't want people to get scared passing this email around. Just don't believe everything that's got some name attached it. I've found this to be very true in all cancer research."

Computer-literate with kin in Detroit stand ready

If you know your way around a computer and if you have family or friends in the Detroit area, be ready for the calls for help.

Today's the day the Detroit newspapers stop coming into homes via paper most days of the week or as the Free Press says, starts a digital era.

So get online, read these new versions (Detroit News or Detroit Free Press) and wait for those calls to come in from your less techie friends and family members struggling to get what they need to know.

I say that even though the Detroit media have done some outreach, knowing that "Eye on Detroit as News changes." I say that knowing that none of the 29 people at my house yesterday knew the changes started today. I say that knowing how often I meet people new to email or Internet browsing.

Certainly, promoting the changes took some thought. I like that the plan is to give away thousands of the newsstand editions today. (I clipped part of a photo offered in a Detroit News gallery, showing how some of the hawkers hit the street today.)

Can you pull the plug for love?

How much of being on is too much? Should you send out Twitters to those who didn't pay to get to or into a conference? If you are there on a press pass? There because you paid to get in? Or there courtesy of someone who wanted you in the seats?

Or let's get personal as Susan Mernit recently did,

Is it polite to keep the laptop on top of your lap when your chatting with friends or family? Is it right to send out Twitters when your suggled up next to your sweetie? When you are the car's nagavator, charged with getting the driver from here to there?

My family and non-journalism friends do not understand why the closing of the Ann Arbor News or changes at the other Advance Newspapers sent me to the web searching for details. My daughter is amazed that I constantly use my iPhone or pull out the laptop, not to play a game but to know what's up, to read what others say and share my own thoughts.

Still, I am able to set aside all devices when family calls - did I mention 29 folks expected today at my house? - as no obligation to an employer reinforces the ingrained need to know.

Read Susan's post on Devices and love while I'm tending to love. I'll return to the devices tomorrow.

Oh no! Brenda fired!

On Saturday, the publisher threatened Brenda Starr with a furlough. On Sunday, Brenda says no and is fired. Yes, the comics are the real world once more.... Right down to a person saying "let's help a reporter and buy a newspaper" only to be told not to bother as the news is free online. See the Starr reporter online.

Do you have a road map to tomorrow?

To live "perfect life" you need to define that life first. That's the advice from a journalist who now works on the business side of the business. In "Decide what you want and declare it," she shares:

"When I hear people complaining about their jobs, I encourage them to make a list of attributes of their perfect job. I did that before I landed my position three years ago, from wanting to work at company I respected and that would look good on my resume to wanting an office with windows and the ability to listen to music at my desk. I got nearly everything on my list, including pay and vacation time."

A related post by the blogger Colleen Newvine Tebeau, who grew up in Saginaw, Michigan, and posts in the Newvine Growing blog is:

Don’t do what works for other people — make your list in a way that works for you

You might find this post of mine helpful:
Resume-building sites, blogging advice can help you

Could Advance workers tap into job perk?

Any chance that employees of Advance Publications affected by salary and job cuts can take advantage of a new American City Business Journals relationship?

There was a time when employees at Advance Publications newspapers could get discounted books and magazines produced by other arms of the family-owned business. I don't remember any of the American City Business Journals being part of that offer, but the web site says:

American City is a unit of Advance Publications Inc., which also operates Conde Nast Magazines, Parade magazine, Fairchild Publications, the Golf Digest companies, Newhouse Newspapers and cable television interests.

A March 15 press release says BizjournalsHire.com, the new media division at American City Business Journals,will offer JobSniper's free professional career evaluation and job search tools at BizjournalsHire.com's recently revamped network of career sites.

I'm not sure if there are any premium services available, but I do know there are quite a few employees in and outside the newsroom who are scrambling for income.

The press release promises:

"... a free detailed and in-depth, professional online career evaluation to all bizjournalshire.com users.

"Those completing the free online career evaluation will also be given free access to additional career resources such as job hunting skills tests, search agents, sample resumes, sample cover letters , career site reviews and much more.

The career services are an extension of business information services, the press release says.

'Our focus has always been to deliver the kinds of information that enable opportunity; we've simply applied those same principles to our career services,' says Michael Montoya, Vice President of Product and Business Development at BizjournalsHire.com

The American City Business Journals are in 40 markets (none in Michigan). The release also says company employs more than 550 business journalists.

By the way, DigiDave recently suggested reading "An open letter to journalists: You have an amazing career opportunity on the Dark Side" Check it out.

You might also find these posts helpful:

• Resume-building sites, blogging advice can help you
• Jobs for journalists via RSS
• Talent will outlast jobs, careers
• Beyond the buyout, beyond the bylines for journalists
• Buyout journalists, remember this ..
• It hurts to laugh; it helps to prepare

Half the facts enough for Jersey Backup

Is The Jersey Backup filling a void by providing all the news and half the facts?

My husband will be so sad to learn NJ Phasing Out Traffic Circles, Introduces Concave Polygons. He's soooo into traffic.

Here's the description of the site, which the Baristanet says is run by a former employee of The Star-Ledger and Maplewood Patch identifies as Gary Saitz

We know you want your New Jersey news unfiltered, with just as much toxicity as you’d find at the bottom of the Passaic River. So we’re here to help. Real news may give you facts. The Jersey Backup gives you the truth.

The about page clearly explains the intent:

The Jersey Backup is the latest incarnation of what has been a long and proud lineage of muckraking publications. It all started in 1879 with the Bloomfield Bullshitter, which bravely noted former general and current Gov. George Brinton McClellan lost a key battle during the Civil War to a herd of poorly shorn sheep.

In the ensuring years, the publication bounced around the Garden State and was variously known as the Denville Dissembler, the Hamburg Humbug and the Jersey Journal. All the while, its staff kept true to the enduring belief that all New Jersey residents should know that what they’re reading is absolutely, positively, 100 percent true."

Check out the news.

Is Advance the surviving five-and-dime?

I reveal my age by referring to Kresege as a five-and-dime store in this day of dollar stores where things cost more then $1.

Still, I found this comparison of Advance and AdvanceInternet (and its new AnnArbor.com) to Kresege and Kmart on/borrellassociates.com worth reading.

Perhaps it is because I know the day is coming when some will remember newspapers with the same fondness I reserve for Kresege with its aisles of simple choices - the eight colors of thread, not 15 shades of blue; a few boxed games for children, not an entire store of toys and socks galore as long as black or white will suffice.

Check out the blog post that compares the strategies of retail and media companies.

What's being said about and by Advance, AnnArbor.com, Michigan newspapers

Here's some of the latest reporting and blogging about the changes at the Michigan newspapers under the Advance Publication umbrella.

Twitter was still talking, with items like "Being a journalist is a privilege. Who else gets to cover their own funeral" and Tim McGuire saying:

"blogged today on drastic actions at Newhouse's Michigan papers. It's at McGuire on Media. It's got nostalgia AND melancholy."

The Michigan native talks about Michigan newspapers grapple with dramatic solutions.

"Numbness is starting to replace sadness with all these industry downsizing efforts , but the level of experimentation at the Michigan Newhouse papers is admirable. Everybody seems focused on finding the right business revenue models and that search is struggling. This search for the for the right cost model to responsibly serve readers is just as important a quest."

Paper Tiger shares more about the AnnArbor.com plans by sharing part two of Tony Dearing's interview. Learn more on hires, ad sales and content.

Crain's Detroit spoke to Steve Newhouse, who is spokesman for the Advance Publications on the consolidations, printing conversions and new online products for the eight Booth newspapers in Michigan. He shares some details on Booth salary cuts, including:

• 15 percent range for Jackson Citizen-Patriot, Grand Rapid Press, Kalamazoo Gazette and Muskegon Chronicle.
• Up to 50 percent for 345 employees at Bay City Times, Flint Journal and Saginaw News (145 up to 25%, 100 up to 30%, 75 up to 40% and 25 will make 50 percent less.)

Also discussed is why the move were made and what may be coming.

Grand Rapids Publisher Dan Gaydou is quoted in Editor & Publisher on what printing will be done on the Ann Arbor presses - twice weekly print editions and TMC product each week for Ann Arbor, Advance's Jackson Citizen-Patriot and regional copies of The New York Times. There also is some discussion on the Kalamazoo newspaper.

The CEO of Mlive.com published a letter to answer some questions about how the Ann Arbor changes affect that site.

Also on Mlive.com is Paula Gardner, now editor of the Michigan Business Review, talking about the changing model and reflecting on the closing of the Ypsilanti Press and Ann Arbor News. A colleague had recently shared a 1994 Ann Arbor News Ypsi edition:

"It's ironic to me that yet another story on that 1994 page introduces Tony Dearing as editor of the debuting Ypsilanti Press edition.
Today, he's introduced as chief content leader for www.annarbor.com."

The Review, also under the Advance umbrella, will continue publishing, according to a box inserted in the column on the changing of he news.

"These changes in Ann Arbor will come with pain both internally and in the community. But at this point they also bring hope that a sustainable business model grows in Ann Arbor that supports both the scope for daily news coverage and the professionalism that journalists bring to the job."

Not continuing is the Livingston Community News, a product of the Ann Arbor News. The Livingston Daily publishes a piece on the July ending that will leave 16 people looking for jobs.

The Ypsilanti Courier looks at how the closing of the News and opening of AnnArbor.com will affect its home base while a student at the University of Michigan Dearborn reflects on his chosen career in "Old Newspapers Don't Die, They Go Online."

While on the subject of death, a former Michigan man says he mourns the losses friends in the newspaper world face but he is done mourning newspapers in A Final Look Into the Coffin.

On Sunday, an Ann Arbor News reporter who already lost a job through a newspaper closing worried her newspaper might go to three-days a week. Read her thoughts in A column I never wanted to write as she rebounds from the closing of a second newspaper in her life.

The Ann Arbor Chronicle led me to "The Internet is not my newspaper" by sharing this from Mark O'Brien's Random Camera blog:

“It’s a sad commentary that a city the size of Ann Arbor cannot support a daily newspaper. I know that things have been tough on newspapers all over the country. But I wonder is it truly symptomatic of declining advertising revenues because of the web that some papers are going under, or is it the result of larger syndicates and big corporations that have only the shareholder’s interest, and not that of the people that they serve?"

Ken Doctor in Content Bridges looks at many of the changes coming to Michigan and echos a question:

"What's the difference between an "online-only" product, with two or three weekly editions (the Ann Arbor model) and three-day-a-week "daily" newspapers with stronger online presence? (Flint-Bay City-Saginaw)"

In the same thoughtful post, he concludes:

"It's one of intention. It's one of seeing the world through a new lens -- the way it is, rather than the way it was, newspaper-filtered and newspaper-mediated."

I encourage you to read "Michigan's spawns new hybrid age of news(papers) for its dance through the possibilities.

Let's end with a more optimistic Twitter find. Jeff Jarvis passed along a tweet from long-time friend Dave Morgan( davemorgannyc on Twitter:

"the Advance/Newhouse move in Michigan: bold, market-leading and right on target."

High praise from the man Jarvis once wanted to hire for Advance Internet and is behind online ad ventures Real Media, Tacoda , and now a self-described "entrepreneur working on the next big thing."

The Ann Arbor News, by the way, caught up with Jarvis to talk about the changes:

"What we need right now is a lot of development, invention and experiments. We will find a way to do it online. ... It is a time of great challenge for all of us in the newspaper industry. It is also a time of critically important innovation. There will be some tremendous learning.''

Reporter Tom Gannert also talked to Randy Siegel, president of Parade Publications and co-founder of the Newspaper Project:

"I think this is a new era in experimentation,. It is a very bold, strategic move. There is certainly some risk involved. But if it works out well, it will help a lot of other newspaper companies around the country figure out their respective strategies.''

(I wrote about his piece on the newspaper naysayers in Watching the Newhouse spiral)

That's it. On to new topics, family matters and housekeeping.

Facebook quiz leads to post-journalism jobs

"Take a buyout? Get laid off? Or just plain quit your media job? Find out what you should do next."

That's the intro to a new quiz on Facebook. Go ahead. Answer 10 questions like:

• What was your proudest moment in journalism?
  
• What do you do when you hear sirens?
• How many times have sources called your editor?
• Turn your keyboard upside down and shake. What comes out?

Some have been told they should become bartenders, hacks, and flack, a position that comes with this message:

"You're destined for the dark side. The good news: the money is better. The bad news: your soul is sold."

What kind of post-journalism job should I get? -- click here to find out!

Don't like the questions or answers? There's a link so you can create your own quiz.

AnnArbor.com evolving, product leaders tell Michigan bloggers, journalists

The details on what are fuzzy, but it is clear that the Newhouse organization believes it has found the perfect community and time to create new products for a media organization.

"We're starting from zero, and we're going to do what we should do," Tony Dearing who heads up the content development for the new product, told employees of the Ann Arbor News on the day the Michigan workers learned of the newspaper's end. "... Because it doesn't exist, it's hard to explain what it is, or what's it going to be"

But Tony and AnnArbor.com president Matt Kraner spent much of Monday trying to describe it - the AnnArbor.com, an online community information center that also will birth a new print product twice weekly, - to Michigan audiences. They also expanded the product's reach with a Facebook page and Twitter account, where one Tweet suggested an "information ecosystem" is more of what we hope to grow.

Dearing and Kraner talked with newspaper employees. Dearing also called two former Ann Arbor News employees who head up their own online ventures. (I had to postpone my update from my former boss.)

Jim Carty, sports writer turned law student and blogger frequently posting on his former newspaper, posted part one of his hour-plus interview with Tony early Tuesday and promised two more Q&A installments.

Also posted on Paper Tiger is a transcript of Dearing and Kraner addressing the Ann Arbor News staff Monday afternoon at a local hotel. Carty said the source was an A2 News employee who taped it for personal use.

Tony also talked to Mary Morgan, who is the publisher of The Ann Arbor Chronicle, an online local news publication started in September 2008. He told Carty that the Chronicle's mews feed was one of about 20 that he reads daily. Tony also praised the Chronicle in several interviews, including:

"Her passion and her commitment says that as good as the Ann Arbor News' reporting is, there are other things you can be doing as well."

Morgan, who worked a number of jobs such as business and opinion editor during her 12 years at the News, saw that coverge was updated through out the day on her site and also wrote a column on Why we grieve the Ann Arbor News" while dealing with her mother's death.

In Paper Tiger's first part of the Dearing interview you'll find a brief outline of staffing for AnnArbor.com, some philosophy and some of the challenges expected. There seems to be a startup thinking, including outsourcing tasks that others can do better. It also seems like the project will try borrowing from innovators, heavy into linking, and trying to blend journalistic ways with people's growing interest in connecting online.

The Ann Arbor area was picked to go with this new venture because of its demographics, including a younger population that is more likely to rent then own their living quarters, and the network of better Internet connections & usage that is higher other Michigan markets.

I don't have any inside information - that is just what I have gleaned online and over the years working with Tony and some of the others working on the project.

Tony is a long time print journalist who has worked at becoming comfortable online. (Ask him about Idol Chatter and Lakisha Jones). Those efforts included his own blog while at The Flint Journal and encouraging others to develop online skills. A few years ago, he also organized an AP Michigan editors panel on new media that I was on.

By the way, Detroit's Crain's interviewed Steve Newhouse, chairman of advance.net after the Newhouse family made public its decision to close the Ann Arbor News and reduce publication days, jobs and benefits at its other Michigan newspapers. Booth Newspapers is a subsidiary of New York City-based Advance Publications Inc. that’s owned by the Newhouses.

Jeff Jarvis, who has been involved with Advance Internet for many years and helped in the planning of the latest online project, also blogged about the Ann Arbor project. But he said little beyond

"They are holding community meetings starting in April to do that. I’ll talk more about the project as its proceeds. "

I expect to keep talking about the project and other changes in the world around me even as I make my daughter's battle against breast cancer my number one priority.

As someone who first got online when you needed a university or science connection, these are exciting times. As someone who has worked for six newspapers and with another eight, these are painful times. Eleven months into my own buyout-funded sabatical, I have more questions then answers.

Is it time for Internship or multimedia training?

In the midst of the newspaper layoffs and buyouts, it was refreshing to see that something that might actually help you get a journalism job, even in this rotten economy.

Rob Curley is pretty specific in saying what he wants, especially noting that skillset is important. but mindset is most important. He also says:

"It means we’re looking for at least a couple of people to help us on the news side of lasvegassun.com, a journalist to help us with lasvegasweekly.com, a sports journalist to help us across all of our sites, and a video journalist to help us with our upcoming, new daily television show.

"We want solid journalists who can write their backsides off. (Unless you’re applying for the videographer position, and even then you should still be able to write well, as well as be able to shoot and edit your backside off.)

"We’re also looking for programmers with an understanding of Django. And if you’re a designer with killer Flash or motion-graphics skills, we want you."

Those positions are internships and details about length, pay, etc. are in the post.

Pay, imagine that. So different from what the former managing editor ofthe TV Guide is getting, according to the The Los Angeles Times. Lois Draegin, who was laid off from her TV Guide job in spring 2008 ,is an unpaid intern at wowOwow.com, the Women on the Web site aimed at those over 40.

She took the internship as a way to fill out her resume and learn more about URLs, SEO and other Internet items, reports Geraldine Baum. . Her first first story received 200 clicks, whereas her second drew 5,000. The Times story talks about what she's learning and what a much younger intern is learning. wowOwow sees Executive Interns as a way to fight recession. A separate wowOwow items suggests that others should consider creating Executive Interships.

If you are laid off or furloughed, you might want to listen to Angela Grant who suggests on News Videographer that you become a multimedia wizard.

She was inspired by a blog post on a free six-week training opportunity that teaches you "to produce cutting edge content for TV, radio, online and mobile." First, one week of intense training. Second, four weeks getting paid to produce multimedia for a real news organization. Third, another week of intense training. The only catch — INFUZE is in the UK and the deadline is past.

But Grant said it gave her an idea:

"If you were unfortunate enough to get laid off recently, this may be a good opportunity to take the time to teach yourself how to shoot video. No pressure, plenty of time. It would certainly sweeten you up and make you stand out in the harsh job market."

I suggest you start with reading NewsVideographer and look for the Training Sites listed on the right site of the blog. She includes a number of possibilities, including:

• Camp VJ
• Current.tv Producer Training
• Digital Video Information Network
• Knight Digital Media Center
• Lynda.com video training
• Make Internet TV
• Newspaper Video Ning Group
• NewspaperVideo Yahoo Group
• The Compelling Image
• Visual Editor
• Wired Journalists
• YouTube video toolbox

FUZE suggested that folks should look at

• Dipity - make interactive timelines
• Blip.tv,Vimeo orYouTube - for video
• Animoto,SlideShare,Vuvox or Soundslides

I still like the Mastering Multimedia blog, especially this entry: "Stop bitchin' and just train yourself." And despite the gloomy outlook for many right, now the blog author is still optimistic about newspaper video surviving.

And I'm sorry that I don't remember who shared this link first, but you can find 100 free open courses on journalism, bloging and new media here.

By the way, Kmart has the Flip video cameras on sale this week. They are not the world's best cameras, but you can do a lot with them. A quick start at a low price.

And this just in from Mostly Media: KSU's Center For Sustainable Journalism Hiring A Director

Hey Atlanta journos - especially recently laid-off ones: KSU’s Center For Sustainable Journalism, co-founded by SoCon co-founder, Leonard Witt, is hiring a director. This is an exciting opportunity for the right person. Details are here.

You might find these posts helpful:

• Resume-building sites, blogging advice can help you
• Jobs for journalists via RSS
• Talent will outlast jobs, careers
• Beyond the buyout, beyond the bylines for journalists
• Buyout journalists, remember this ..
• It hurts to laugh; it helps to prepare

Why May for Advance pension changes and other musings online about Monday's talks

I'm rushed so just some of the things I've picked up about Advance Publications changes out on the web and in my RSS feeds.

Pensions are not easy to understand, so this blog post on NJ Voices helps explain some of the technical parts. Read Trust the Ledger, not New Jersey, on pension changes.

For instance, why mid-May for benefit changes?

"They froze benefit accruals so the funding hole wouldn't get deeper. In general, any amendment that reduces the rate of future accruals requires a 45-day advance notice to participants [ERISA §204(h)]. That's why they told people today so nobody would accrue past mid-May. That May date is also important since most benefit accruals for the year require 1,000 hours of service. If benefits are frozen prior to achieving 1,000 hours in 2009, there is no 2009 benefit accrual."

Blogger John Bury is an Enrolled Actuary with his own pension consulting firm in Montclair, New Jersey. He shares a link to other pension plans here.

And while we're cruising in New Jersey I discovered TV watching was tough for Allan Sepinwall, the TV critic of The Star-Ledger. He writes the blog What's Alan Watching and said this about How I Met Your Mother:

"Now, admittedly, today's news at the paper may well have made it impossible for me to enjoy a storyline about fake jobs, Ted being on the verge of getting fired, a room designed for firing people, etc., but I don't think so. The biggest laugh I had at the episode was the security cam montage of Barney firing people"

Some of the Newhouse newspapers published letters from the publishers online, including the Oregonian. A letter from the Oregonian publishers Fred and Patrick Stickel details changes within that newspaper and told employees how to calculate their pension benefits.

There was a blog post and an article posted on OregonLive about the changes that include the Stickels and editor Sandy Rowe taking 15 percent pay cuts while other staff will see salaries reduced 5-10 percent; pensions will be frozen in May with company contributions to 401ks increasing. Also some circulation changes coming and some part-timers will lose their jobs.

A slightly different take is offered in this article Oregonian issues furloughs, pension freeze after losing millions.

The Cleveland Plain Dealer announced its cuts and warned more changes may come.

"President Terrance C. Z. Egger announced that full-time, non-union employees must take 10 days of unpaid leave between April 20 and Oct. 4.Full-time and part-time non-union employees will see their first $50,000 of pay cut by 8 percent and any additional pay reduced by 10 percent as of June 1. The furloughs involve 370 employees. Pay cuts will affect about 450 of the Plain Dealer's 1,055 workers. The newspaper also is evaluating its employee benefits packages and could make changes this summer."

An Oregon blogger wrote that a 10 percent pay cut is 90 percent better than laid off but starts off:

"I felt like I was at a funeral today and that is so incredibly sad to me.

Then, the blogger shares the better attitude:

"At the same time, I feel incredibly blessed and fortunate to work for Advance - most other papers have layed off much of their staff, cut benefits, frozen 401K matches and reduced salaries. I am still employed, I still have great benefits for myself and my husband (we certainly need those right now) and I still get to say that I work for one of the best papers in the country. I just wish I was confident that I would have that long-term. But as someone I know said recently, "nothing lasts forever."

Meanwhile, the demise of the Ann Arbor News brings out support for newspapers from Ann Arbor blogger Mark Maynard:

"Newspapers, when they function well, invest time and money in cultivating leads, checking facts and really digging into stories. They demand accountability. The bottom line is, I don’t know that I’d want to live in a community that isn’t served by real journalists."

The changes brought some reminiscing. In Old newspapers don't just die, they .... Mark Silvia says

"As someone who spent some of his most memorable early years in the business in Michigan, at the Muskegon Chronicle - it took me four hours to get there from Saginaw - and who once traveled to corporate headquarters in Ann Arbor for some management screening which included a couch-session with a psychiatrist - which could be considered essential to continuing work in journalism today - we could not help but wince at today's news of the Ann Arbor News ceasing publication."

Tom Wickham, who has worked at a number of the Michigan Advance newspapers, remembers what happened during his years as a Newhouse employee in No celebrating here before moving onto the issue of newspapers.

"Frankly, I agree that the newspapers need to adapt to survive. But it does nothing to assuage the melancholy feeling that came over me today when I read the news, online, of course. I immediately tweeted the story to others in my network and I placed a link on my Facebook page."

Wickham also replied in another post to a former friend celebrating the demise of newspapers.

"It is sad that you see the death of newspapers as something to celebrate. While you are entitled to your opinion, your comments cut deep. The people impacted by the changes are my dear friends. Many will lose their jobs. Some, I am sure, even share the political views as you do, but seem to be justifiable collateral damage in your eyes."

Fitz and Jen talk about the "three forces that killed Ann Arbor News" on the E&P site.

But let's end on a more positive note with a thoughtful post assuring all that journalism is not ending comes from Jane Briggs-Bunting, who is director of the J-School at Michigan State University. She starts by noting the effects of the economy and changes born because of technology.

“ The times have changed. The news and information delivery models will be different. And news organizations like newspapers, TV and radio are scrambling to catch up (and frankly, somehow must have missed that press release when Tim Berners-Lee developed the World Wide Web, or Craigslist started running free classified and…the list goes on and on.”

Make no mistake, these are not easy times.

"This is shake up, break up and then we will make it up. The founding fathers didn’t protect a free press in the 1st Amendment to be nice guys. They did it because they got it that someone had to watchdog government and the press was the one entity to do that—fearlessly.....
....So hang on. This makes the worst roller coaster in the world look like a kiddie ride. This is scary, challenging, thrilling, fun and most of us will live through it and even benefit.

Change can be good - even in Facebook

Change is tough ... on all fronts. But trust me, you're going to get used to the new Facebook. And if you're a reporter, or just someone dying to know something, Facebook will become a more valuable tool.

I was able to follow what was happening with some Michigan newspapers because I had assigned some contacts to groups that let me scan their status updates and postings quickly by filtering my newsfeed on the opening page

The pages for causes, businesses and organizations are becoming more valuable. In some ways, they remind me of the early days of geocities, angelfire and other templated sites that made it easy for almost anyone to build a web site and get traffic easily.

Lots of changes, but as Stacy Lukasavitz from Fenton, Michigan, says in Attention: Facebook Luddites — STOP WHINING!:

"Social sites, much like software, much like hardware, much like anything, evolve over time. Changes will be made as more people use a product. You may not like all of them, but the usability that Facebook has now is tremendous compared to when it began. When you first started listening to mp3s, did you kick and scream to bring CDs back? When you first started listening to CDs, did you cry and complain that you wanted cassette tapes back? Not bloody likely."

Out on the web, some bloggers help me understand some of the possibilities of Facebook. For instance, Rob Diana wrote about mining Facebook for data, building on a Chris Messina *post on the value achieved online when everyone uses their own names. Robert Scoble goes further on illustrating how Facebook could be a goldmine for marketers, using his new father-to-be status as a down-to-earth example.

Jesse Stay from Stay N' Alive shows how some coming Facebook features means The Potential for Facebook Search Kicks Twitter’s butt. His explanations helped me a lot.

Some of the possibility depends on your definition of Facebook friends. It's a subject that came up recently in a family discussion - one member doesn't believe I could know everyone on my list.

So I loved it that Robert Scoble nailed the subject of friends in Scoble responsible for destroying the utility of the social graph. It means I have to ask:

Are we friends? Are we connected on Facebook? Know me well enough for LinkedIn? Or just want to see what I'm doing online via FriendFeed?


* This post was updated because I had Chris Messina's first name wrong. I've apologized.

Michigan newspapers announce changes; new online effort in Ann Arbor

The chain of newspapers informally known as Booth Newspapers announced changes today that include the closing of the Ann Arbor News, the opening of a hybrid online-print product that invites community participation, three editions instead of seven for three newspapers, and salary and benefit cuts for the newspaper employees.

Employees at other newspapers in the Newhouse/Advance Publication alliance also are reporting salary and benefit cuts.

AnnArbor.com (video below) will offer news coverage to the Ann Arbor market. It will be a site independent of the mive.com joint site now serving the eight Booth Newspapers. A print product, created out of Jackson, will be available on Thursdays and Sundays. Plus, the operation will seek community input in designing the product and contributing to the coverage.

The Bay City Times, Flint Journal, and Saginaw News will print three times a week instead of seven times. Printing operations will be combined. Plus, some sections will be the same, including the new Diversions (TV listings, puzzles and advice), Social (friends and family news), Let's Go (what to do where) and Posh. There's also a hint about a Great Lakes Bay news section on the Bay City and Saginaw announcements.

(Update via Twitters from employees: Flint, Saginaw, Bay City newspapers 35% layoffs; pension freeze May 14 but more to 401k; 25% pay cuts; job pledge void)

Salary and benefit cuts were announced for employees at the Kalamazoo Gazette, Grand Rapids Press, Jackson Citizens Patriot and Muskegon Chronicle.

Editorial production for Kalamazoo and Muskegon newspapers moves to Grand Rapids this summer. The Kalamazoo publisher also says its printing operation may also move to Grand Rapids.

Here are links to Michigan announcements:

Ann Arbor News Press Release March 23

Ann Arbor News to close in July. AnnArbor.com will launch with daily reporting on the web and a bi-weekly print edition (Thursdays and Sundays). (Note: The site is live, public meetings set up so community can contribute)

Letter from Ann Arbor News Publisher March 23

This is a difficult day for all of us at The Ann Arbor News. I've announced to my colleagues here that we will publish our last edition in July.

Coverage on mlive March 23

The Ann Arbor News will close in July and will be replaced by a Web-based, media company called AnnArbor.com

The Flint Journal announces big changes
Beginning June 1, The Journal, The Saginaw News and The Bay City Times will publish intensely local print editions only on Thursdays, Fridays and Sundays, which research shows are the highest readership days for newspapers.

A letter from the Journal publisher
Frequently asked questions and answers for Journal readers

Saginaw News announces changes

Grand Rapids Press institutes salary, benefit cuts
GRAND RAPIDS - The Grand Rapids Press will reduce wages and add cost-sharing provisions to the health benefit package for all employees beginning in June, Publisher Dan Gaydou announced Monday.The announcement comes as a response to the slow economy and its impact on advertisers.


Kalamazoo editorial production to move

Editorial production center to open in Grand Rapids this summer, looking at joint printing operation

Jackson paper to to print new Ann Arbor product

The Jackson operations will print the twice weekly edition of AnnArbor.com product (Coming out on Thursdays and Sundays. The publisher also said that wages and benefit reductions are planned.


A note to Chronicle readers from Publisher and Editor Paul M. Keep

Bay City Forward - Information on the future of The Bay City Times

Geek gurus on end of dead-tree media wrong, rants SFgate columnist

Out in San Francisco, Mark Moford has had it and he's not going to take it any more from the 'smart, motley crew of big-name, big-brained tech seers and programmers and futurists" known only by Slashdot regulars, co-founder of Digg, those with "a fetish for hardcore database programming" or stargazers at the SXSW Interactive event.

Oh yeah, Moford has had it with Clay "Thinking the Unthinkable" Shirkey and Dave "If you Don't Like the News" Winer, and Steven "Old Growth Media" Johnson and the others who predict the end of newspapers. He lays out his arguments in a post titled "Die, newspapers, die!" and even includes links to the works that set him off.

It basically boils down to a belief that a newspaper - in print or online - means:

"you immediately have an anchor, some credibility and authority, not to mention a sense of place and context. In whatever you read, you know there has been, at minimum, some real editorial oversight and integrity of product borne of trained, experienced editors and writers who, believe it or not, still value accuracy and truth above all else.

Don't believe me? I understand. Get your contemptuous butt into a real, extant newsroom (yes, before they're all gone), sit in on a few editorial meetings, talk to actual reporters who haven't yet been laid off, see how the meat is made, and decide for yourself."

Please do read his words so carefully put together. But - spoiler alert - just know that the man is on Facebook and jas a Twitter account besides his column on sfgate.com. The bottom line, I think, is he wants to make sure that someone will keep paying for content.

A newspaper's blogger's apology for silence gets debate on newspapers, politics going

Andrew Heller, a Flint Journal columnist who now blogs a lot, recently apologized to his online readers for being more quiet then usual. The reaction was unexpected.

"Well, it's nice to see I can launch an entire media/politics discussion with a mere apology."

The responses were all over the map, with many focusing on why people don't read newspapers. Blaming lifestyle, the liberal bias of newspapers, and oh so much more.

The newest comments are at the top and there's no threading so start at the bottom of page.

Dreamers can help publishers keep offering luxury of 'unplugged content'

I started my morning by reading a print edition of a newspaper, currently delivered seven days a week to my home. That reminded me how much I agree with John Blossom that it is a "luxury to spend time reading "unplugged" content."

It's a luxury I've indulged in this week as the changing of chemo treatments for my daughter offered the opportunity to work my way through stacks of magazines that now will go to the waiting rooms of medical facilities in need of new distractions.

Yet, as I turned the pages I realized that I only read certain features and departments of each. That makes me eager for the success of projects like Printcasting and Time MINE. It makes me eager for the success of creative thinkers like those meeting this weekend for RevenuePointTwoZero or on Apil 25 for BarCamp Philly.

Printcasting lets you create a digital, print as a PDF, magazine on any subject. You can see samples for the arts, nutrition and many other subjects.

Time MINE lets you build a magazine from articles found in Time, Travel & Leisure, Real Simple, Sports Illustrated, Food and Wine, Money, InStyle and Golf or delivery by email or post office box.

As I clipped a few cartoons that will likely end up in collaged cards for friends and family, I realized I'd soon be missing pieces of the stories told on comic pages. I wondered why all the publishers are picking the same days to publish. Wouldn't those of us still attracted to print subscribe to another newspaper if it filled a void? So I get the Detroit Free Press three days and the Detroit News the other days. Or perhaps the Detroit papers three days and the Michigan East edition the other four.

That gets me agreeing again with John Blossom, on ContentBlogger. His post acknowledges that Time MINE shows "Online Lessons Creep Into Print Content" with its blending of articles in a common publication. He points out that this is just another small step for Time, which already customized some editorial and advertising based on ZIP codes.

"So kudos for Time testing the waters for their MINE publication, but I do hope that major publishers will finally begin to see the light and start enabling the printing of massively customized print and print-formatted publications that aggregate content from whatever sources interest their audiences the most.

"The result will be far higher ad rates, far higher returns on investment and a much more healthy print publishing business in the long run. Let's stop allowing printing presses to go dark in major cities just because the one publishing company running them cannot build a business model to support them.

"Let those printing presses role with whatever content will command the highest interest from audiences from whatever sources produce it, and the money will follow with due haste.

Let's hope so.

Ann Arbor News editor Petykiewicz to retire

The Ann Arbor News, another Advance Publication, followed up the short announcement on its editor's pending retirement with a longer article today. It's a run through of Ed Petykiewicz career at the various Newhouse Advance Publications, including a stint at the Washington Bureau that gave him insight to the company he has worked for:

"In Washington, which is a mecca for journalists, I realized the way I was treated and the way other reporters were treated was drastically different."

(It's an experience that most won't be able to repeat. The bureau closed in November as have Washington Bureaus for Copley Newspaper, Des Moines, Hartford, Houston, Pittsburgh, Salt Lake City, San Francisco and Toledo. The Cox chain, publisher of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, the Austin American-Statesman and fifteen other papers, will padlock its DC bureau on April 1.)

Petykiewicz remains optimistic about the future of journalism:

"People ask, will journalism survive and I think it will survive. The way stories are told will be different and the way they are delivered will be different. But it's the journalists who have fairness and objectivity who will be sought out online. ... I believe we are on a short timeline for the printed newspaper."

His advice for people just entering the field of journalism:

"If you are going to do it, make sure you are well (educated) on the technical side as well as the journalism side. ... If you are not resilient, go somewhere else."

Perhaps most telling is the response to the challenges he faced as an editor:

"The hardest, toughest part of my career, the toughest thing I ever had to do, was the three days when I had to sit down with everyone in the newsroom and talk to them about the buyout. It was draining for me. It was unbelievably hard."

And though the man who first went to school thinking he'd become a lawyer says he's retiring now to avoid making the mistake his father did - "I'm not someone who wants to die in the saddle." - don't you wonder how much the current situation played into that decision.

Related articles:
Flint Journal Editor Tony Dearing joining Advance Internet